The main idea is that fiber-reinforced composites are highly anisotropic: properties depend a lot on the direction of the load relative to the fiber axis. Carbon fibers are very stiff and strong along their length, so when a load acts parallel to the fibers, the material carries most of the load in the fibers themselves, giving the highest stiffness and strength. If the load is at an angle to the fiber direction (off-axis), the fibers can’t contribute as effectively, and the matrix and the fiber–matrix interface must carry more of the load, which results in much lower stiffness and strength. In carbon fiber/epoxy, this difference is especially stark, so properties are strongest along the fiber direction and are reduced in off-axis directions. The other statements ignore this directional dependence or claim equal properties in all directions, which isn’t correct for such composites.